I got the similar issue, but I found the solution, thanks for bellini13's suggestion.
make sure "shop domain" & "ssl domain" in "Traffic & SEO" are the same domain. (in production environment, they should be the same)
however, in my test case, I setup http listen port 81, so, the setup will be:
Shop domain => presta.local:81
SSL domain => prestal.local
(Don't specify port 443 in SSL domain, however, you can specify HTTP port, this is very important)